New York Red Bulls0–0
Columbus Crew
Atlanta United4–5Columbus Crew
New York City FC3–2Columbus CrewColumbus Crew1–1
Toronto FC
Chicago Fire2–0Columbus Crew
Orlando City SC1–1Columbus CrewColumbus Crew3–1New York Red Bulls
FC Cincinnati1–0Columbus CrewColumbus Crew4–0FC CincinnatiFC Cincinnati2–1Columbus Crew
