Colorado Springs Switchbacks FC1–1
Phoenix Rising FCColorado Springs Switchbacks FC1–0
Pittsburgh Riverhounds
Columbus Crew2–1
Vancouver WhitecapsColumbus Crew3–1
Atlanta UnitedColumbus Crew1–0
Philadelphia Union
Seattle Sounders FC1–1Columbus Crew
Nashville SC3–0Columbus CrewColumbus Crew2–1
DC UnitedColumbus Crew1–3
Orlando City SC
CD Toluca6–4Columbus Crew
